SBT Car News

Automatic Car Vs Manual: Which Is Better For South African Roads

Automatic Car Vs Manual

In the ever-evolving world of automobiles, one debate that continues to divide car enthusiasts is the choice between automatic cars and manual cars. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, but when it comes to South Africa’s unique road conditions, making an informed decision becomes crucial.

This article aims to delve into the specifics and shed light on the factors that can help South African drivers make the right choice. So, whether you’re navigating Johannesburg’s bustling streets or embarking on an adventurous road trip along the Garden Route, let’s explore the pros and cons of automatic car vs manual.

Understanding Automatic Transmissions

An automatic transmission, as the name suggests, is designed to shift gears automatically, allowing the driver to focus solely on acceleration and braking. This type of transmission utilizes a torque converter or a dual-clutch system to switch between gears smoothly and seamlessly. Therefore, in South Africa, where traffic congestion is common, automatic transmissions have gained popularity due to their convenience and ease of use.

Advantages of Automatic Cars


Effortless Driving: One of the key benefits of automatic cars is the ease of driving they offer. With no need to manually engage the clutch or shift gears, drivers can experience a more relaxed and stress-free journey, especially in stop-and-go traffic situations.

Smooth Gear Changes: Automatic transmissions ensure seamless gear transitions, providing a smooth driving experience. This is particularly advantageous when navigating hilly terrains or tackling steep inclines.

Accessibility: Automatic cars are generally more accessible for drivers with physical disabilities or mobility issues. These cars eliminate the need for clutch control, which can be challenging for some individuals.

Disadvantages of Automatic Cars

Higher Cost: Automatic cars often come with a higher price tag compared to their manual counterparts. The complex technology and additional components required for automatic transmissions contribute to the increased cost.

Lower Fuel Efficiency: Traditionally, automatic cars have been known to consume more fuel compared to manual cars. However, advancements in transmission technology have significantly narrowed this gap in recent years.

Exploring Manual Transmissions

On the other side of the spectrum, manual transmissions offer a more engaging and hands-on driving experience. South Africa’s diverse landscapes, including long stretches of open roads and scenic routes, make manual cars an appealing choice for driving enthusiasts who value control and precision.

Advantages of Manual Cars


Total Control: With a manual transmission, drivers have complete control over gear selection. This can be advantageous when navigating challenging terrains, such as off-road trails or mountainous regions.

Better Fuel Efficiency: Manual cars are generally more fuel-efficient than automatic cars, as the driver can optimize gear shifts to suit the driving conditions and conserve fuel.

Lower Maintenance Costs: Manual transmissions are typically simpler in design and have fewer components compared to automatic transmissions. This results in lower maintenance and repair costs over the vehicle’s lifespan.

Disadvantages of Manual Cars

Stressful in Traffic: In heavy traffic situations, constant clutch engagement and gear changes can lead to driver fatigue and increased stress levels. This aspect makes manual cars less convenient for daily commutes in congested urban areas.

Learning Curve: Mastering the art of driving a manual car requires time and practice. Inexperienced drivers may find it challenging to coordinate clutch control and gear shifts, especially in South Africa’s diverse driving conditions.

Best Automatic Cars for 2023


1. BMW 5 Series

BMW 5 Series

The BMW 5 Series remains a top contender in the luxury sedan segment. Its automatic transmission offers seamless gear shifts, ensuring a smooth and refined driving experience. Moreover, with its advanced safety features, cutting-edge technology, and luxurious interior, the BMW 5 Series exemplifies sophistication and driving pleasure.

2. Mercedes-Benz E-Class


The Mercedes-Benz E-Class combines elegance with performance, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a luxurious and comfortable ride. Equipped with a responsive automatic transmission, the E-Class delivers impressive power and efficiency.

The cabin boasts exquisite craftsmanship and the latest technological advancements, enhancing the overall driving experience.

3. Honda Accord


For drivers seeking a more affordable option without compromising on quality, the Honda Accord offers a compelling choice. Its automatic transmission delivers smooth gear changes and contributes to the car’s excellent fuel efficiency.

With a spacious interior, advanced safety features, and a reputation for reliability, the Honda Accord remains a popular option in the midsize sedan segment.

4. Audi Q5

audi q5

In the realm of luxury SUVs, the Audi Q5 stands out with its refined styling, exceptional performance, and advanced technology. Moreover, the Q5’s automatic transmission provides seamless shifting, further contributing to its impressive acceleration and handling. Additionally, its comfortable cabin, versatile cargo space, and a host of driver-assistance features make the Audi Q5 a vehicle that offers a perfect balance of luxury and practicality.

Best Manual Cars for 2023


1. Ford Mustang GT


The Ford Mustang GT continues to be an icon in the sports car category, and its manual transmission adds to the thrill of driving. With its muscular performance and timeless design, the Mustang GT delivers an exhilarating experience. It boasts precise gear shifts and excellent handling, making it a dream car for enthusiasts who value control and engagement.

2. Subaru WRX STI


The Subaru WRX STI has earned a reputation for its rally-inspired performance and impressive all-wheel-drive capabilities. Equipped with a manual transmission, the WRX STI allows drivers to fully unleash its power and maneuverability.

With its aggressive styling, sport-tuned suspension, and impressive handling dynamics, the WRX STI offers an unmatched driving experience for those seeking adventure on the road.

3. Porsche 911 GT3


For automotive enthusiasts with a taste for high performance, the Porsche 911 GT3 is a true masterpiece. Furthermore, its manual transmission offers precise gear changes, allowing drivers to extract every ounce of performance from this legendary sports car. In addition to its iconic design, the race-inspired engineering and track-worthy performance of the 911 GT3 represent the pinnacle of driving pleasure.

4. Mazda MX-5 Miata

mazda mx 5

The Mazda MX-5 Miata is a beloved roadster that captures the essence of pure driving enjoyment. With its lightweight construction and responsive handling, the MX-5 Miata delivers an unmatched level of agility and fun. Furthermore, its manual transmission provides a direct connection between the driver and the car, ensuring an engaging and exhilarating driving experience.

Making the Right Choice for South Africa

When it comes to choosing between an automatic car vs manual car for South Africa’s roads, several factors should be considered.

Driving Conditions

Evaluate the typical driving conditions you encounter. If you frequently commute through heavy traffic, an automatic car might be more suitable. However, if you often embark on adventurous road trips or enjoy off-road exploration, a manual car could provide the control and responsiveness you need.


Consider your budget and long-term financial commitments. Automatic cars generally have higher upfront costs and may require costlier repairs and maintenance. Manual cars, on the other hand, can offer better fuel efficiency and potentially lower long-term expenses.

Personal Preference

Ultimately, your personal driving style and preference play a significant role in the decision-making process. Some drivers prioritize convenience and ease of use, while others enjoy the engagement and control offered by manual transmissions.


All in all, in the battle of automatic cars vs manual cars, there is no definitive winner. The choice between the two depends on various factors, including your driving habits, road conditions, and personal preferences.

South Africa’s diverse landscapes and road networks offer ample opportunities for both types of transmissions to shine. Whether you opt for the convenience of an automatic car or the thrill of a manual car, what truly matters is finding a vehicle that suits your needs and enhances your driving experience.